File a Claim/Make a Payment Accident Fund Claims # 866-206-5851 Billing # 866-206-5851 Pay Online Berkley One Claims # 855-663-8551 Billing # 855-663-8550 Pay Online EMC Insurance Claims # 800-447-2295 Billing # 888-362-2255 Pay Online Farmers Mutual Claims # 712-852-4287 Billing # 712-852-4287 Pay Online First Comp Claims # 888-500-3344 Billing # 888-500-3344 Pay Online Great American Claims # 800-587-1553 Billing # 800-587-1553 Pay Online Grinnell Mutual Claims # 800-587-1553 Billing # 800-587-1553 Pay Online Hagerty Claims # 877-922-9701 Billing # 877-922-9701 Pay Online Hartford Claims # 800-327-3636 Billing # 800-327-3636 Pay Online Heartland Claims # 800-544-7384 Billing # 800-544-7384 Pay Online ICAP Iowa Claims # 515-278-9400 Billing # 800-383-0116 Pay Online IMWCA Claims # 800-257-2708 Billing # 877-922-5246 Pay Online IMT insurance Claims # 800-274-3531 Billing # 800-274-3531 Pay Online Members Mutual Claims # 712-732-6595 Billing # 800-798-6803 Pay Online Nationwide Claims # 877-669-6877 Billing # 877-669-6877 Pay Online North Star Claims # 800-622-5230 Billing # 888-266-7847 Pay Online Progressive Claims # 800-776-4737 Billing # 800-776-4737 Pay Onine Selective Claims # 877-348-0552 Billing # 877-348-0552 Pay Online SFM Claims # 800-937-1181 Billing # 800-922-5246 Pay Online State Auto Claims # 800-444-9950 Billing # 800-766-1853 Pay Online Westbend Claims # 800-236-5010 Billing # 877-922-5246 Pay Online Resource Menu File a Claim / Pay Online Certificate of Insurance Request Form Add / Remove a Driver Add / Remove Vehicle Address Change Auto I.D. Card Request Form Refer a Friend FAQs